• Home
  • About
  • Explore
  • Faves
  • Primer
  • Resistance
  • Who

immanence

ecoculture, geophilosophy, mediapolitics

Feeds:
Posts
Comments

The beatnik brotherhood

May 25, 2011 by Adrian J Ivakhiv

Graham Harman’s note reiterating his position that Whitehead, Latour, Deleuze, Bergson, and Simondon (among others) do not make up a coherent philosophical “lump” — “pack” or “tribe” might be more colorful terms here (if philosophers were cats, how herdable would they be?) — makes me want to clarify my own position on these thinkers.

Graham argues that they disagree on “the primacy of individuals, or lack thereof,” a question that “is just about the most important decision you can make in metaphysics,” with Whitehead and Latour lining up on a different side of the fence from the others on this question.

I don’t mind agreeing to disagree with Graham, since we seem to be operating with somewhat different starting assumptions here. And since I’m following the work of many others (from James Williams and Keith Robinson and Steven Shaviro and Michael Halewood to Roland Faber and, I’m pretty sure, Isabelle Stengers and maybe even Latour himself), I’m quite prepared to respect Graham’s view on this as a clearly and thoroughly reasoned dissenting opinion, and mine more as a running with the pack (or a pack, as you’ll see). But I thought it worth reiterating what my view is.

I’m not convinced that the question of the primacy of individuals should have primacy in metaphysics because I’m not convinced that different metaphysical systems define individuals in similar and commensurable ways.

Whitehead’s ontological individuals are “actual occasions” (and “nexus” and “societies”). They are fundamentally processes that together make up a pancreativist universe. (If Whitehead’s philosophy isn’t a process philosophy, I don’t know whose is.)

I think that something similar could be said about Latour’s actors/actants, except that he isn’t really a philosopher-metaphysician in the sense that Whitehead is. He’s a sociologist/anthropologist of science and technology who’s developed a meta-theory out of his empirical research, the ontological implications of which aren’t necessarily as self-evident and self-consistent — which is why Harman has had to tease them out the way he has.

Deleuze focuses on the processes, the activities, by which individuals become; and one of Simondon’s central foci is “individuation,” i.e. the process by which individuals emerge. It’s true that there’s a relational “twang” to most French philosophy of the last half century or more (at least French philosophy for export), and that this twang sounds pretty loudly in Deleuze, but I think it resonates almost as loudly in Latour, once one follows how their respective ideas play themselves out. The main difference is that Latour pays a lot of attention to nonhuman things — things entering into networks with other things (which, in Deleuzo-Guattarian terms, is assemblages assembling). He’s not so much interested in the things per se, though, as he is in the associations and collectives they enter into, produce, affect, alter, inhibit, disrupt, and so on. But since they are nonhuman things — and typically the kinds of things we consider to be inanimate — this makes him both very original and a great resource for the object-oriented turn.

At the same time, just as one cannot deny that Whitehead’s philosophy is a philosophy of relational processes (can one, really?), it is difficult to deny that Deleuzo-Guattarianism — or Foucauldianism, for that matter — lend themselves exceedingly well to what amounts to individualism. All the hundreds of pages they devoted to the assemblage and the rhizome, to becomings, to concepts and affects and percepts and all the rest do not take away from the fact that Deleuze, at least, believed in the immanence of “a life,” a singularity, a haecceity, an event, a becoming. Is this really so opposed to Whitehead’s actual occasion, wrapped as it is in the past it responds to and the future it opens up to?

So if we bracket out our particular assumptions about what an “individual” is and instead follow how the ideas of a philosopher play themselves out, I think there are deep and abiding family resemblances between Whitehead, Deleuze, Bergson, Simondon, Stengers, James, Peirce, et al. In any case, reading Thinking With Whitehead will either convince me, or it won’t, that if there is a single fence separating metaphysical camps, Stengers will line up on the same side of it as Whitehead, Latour, and Deleuze.

 

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • More
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Related

Related posts:

  1. Harman’s object-oriented philosophizing
  2. still process-relations all the way down
  3. Thinking with Whitehead
  4. NT6: Morton: “They are here”
  5. Toward telling an adequate story
  6. Things slip away… (on Harman’s Latourian object lessons)
  7. More on Harman, or what’s outside the system of relations?
  8. subjects & objects, together or apart…

Posted in Philosophy, Process-relational thought | Tagged Continental philosophy, Deleuze, Harman, Latour, Stengers, Whitehead | 5 Comments

5 Responses

  1. on May 25, 2011 at 10:12 am Paul

    Interesting. Deleuze and Guattari do have a concept of ‘primary true forms’, and ‘absolute interiorities’, taken partly/largely from Raymond Ruyer’s neo-leibnizian ‘psycho-biology’ (ruyer’s term). See the conclusion to ‘What is Philosophy’. I gave a brief account of Ruyer in a rough old essay ‘Subjectless Subjectivities’ (in Massumi’s collection ‘A Shock to Thought’). Even in 1000 plateaus they ask ‘but is there not some minimal subject onto which assemblages are grafted….but I doub’t they’d say that everything is ‘explained’ by individuals. Not sure everything can be ‘explained’…
    However, I doubt that Stengers would line up anywhere soon….except perhaps as a witch.


  2. on May 25, 2011 at 10:22 am Adrian J Ivakhiv

    Good point, Paul – “lining up” is the wrong image, for so many reasons. Like those cats… (And “explaining” too.) “Circle ’round” perhaps, and even “process” (that’s the verb, accent on the “cess,” processions being the kinds of things even witches might do, as long as their paths are circuitous, spiralling, or somehow non-linear).


  3. on May 25, 2011 at 4:34 pm Paul

    Btw, Stengers does see a rough version of actual entities in desiring machines in the Whitehead bk….in the section ‘Justifying Life (Justifier la vie)’. It starts by discussing the diff btwn crystals and animals….I don’t have an english copy.
    In fact desiring machines have the characteristics of autopoiesis (which Guattari was well aware of).
    Eric Alliez also had something interesting comments on W. in ‘The Signature of the World: what is the phil of D/G? He was a student of Deleuze’s – it’s a good bk.

    Guattari does give a provisional definition of subjectivity in Chaosmosis (p.4) as “the ensemble of conditions which render possible the emergence of individual and/or collective instances as self-referential existential territories, adjacent, or in a delimiting relation, to an alterity that is in itself subjective.”

    So that’s all sorted – let’s dance


  4. on May 27, 2011 at 4:59 am Christian Evensen

    I feel Deleuze could have made the argument Graham says he wouldn’t. At least the Spinozist Deleuze, if we understand modes or affects as individuals in some sense. From D&R: “Substance must itself be said OF the modes and only OF the modes.” (p. 50) Substance is dependent on the modes (at least in Deleuze’s view, as part of his making substance turn on the modes), so there is a primacy of modes or affects.


  5. on June 4, 2011 at 9:25 pm Jenn

    That’s an interesting argument put forth by Graham. The discussion seems to be going in the right direction.



Comments are closed.

  • Categories

    • Academe (108)
    • Anthropocene (79)
    • Blog stuff (53)
    • Cinema (89)
    • Climate change (77)
    • Cultural politics (47)
    • Eco-culture (179)
    • Eco-theory (59)
    • Manifestos & auguries (46)
    • Media ecology (130)
    • Music & soundscape (39)
    • Philosophy (265)
    • Politics (178)
    • Process-relational thought (104)
    • Science & society (39)
    • Spirit matter (135)
    • Uncategorized (66)
    • Visual culture (90)
  • Archives

  • Subscribe2


     

  • Popular resources

    Trump 2.0 critical resource list

    Indigenous identity in Vermont: resources

    Lyme disease & beyond: a bibliographic resource

    Humming the New Earth (on the "global Hum")

    33⅓ Environmental Studies greats (or, a canon revisited) (2015)

    Process-relational theory primer

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2020

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2010

    Between Continental and environmental philosophy (2009)

  • Publications

    Terra Invicta: Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth

    The New Lives of Images: Digital Ecologies & Anthropocene Imaginaries in More-than-Human Worlds

    Routledge Handbook of Ecomedia Studies

    Shadowing the Anthropocene: Eco-Realism for Turbulent Times

    Ecologies of the Moving Image: Cinema, Affect, Nature

    Claiming Sacred Ground: Pilgrims and Politics at Glastonbury and Sedona

    Academia.edu (various articles; requires registration)

  • Selected talks & interviews

    Terra Invicta book launch, U. Tallinn, 2025

    Ecologies of the Multipolar Information Disorder, SFU, 2025

    Apocalyptic Anxieties, SFU, 2023

    Toward the Symbiocene talk, 2023 (good first stop!)

    SFU Global Humanities interview

    KCSB Selectric Davyland interview

    The Zone is Us (Vermont Humanities, 2022)

    Krista Tippett On Being (Speaking of Faith) interview

    Imperfect Buddha podcast

    More links here

  • Music

    Bandcamp music page

    What's on my Bandcamp music page

    Soundcloud playlist (music sampler)

    "As Pluto Descends" trilogy

    10 greatest albums of the 'album era'
  • Associated sites

    Terrestri(e)alism

    EcoCultureLab: Enter the Feverish World

    EcoCultureLab blog

    Media+Environment journal

    M+E+ blog

    UKR-TAZ: A Ukrainian Temporary Autonomous Zone

  • This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States license.
  • wordpress visitors

Get a free blog at WordPress.com

Theme: Mistylook by Sadish.


Skip to toolbar
  • UVM Blogs
    • WordPress
      • About WordPress
      • Get Involved
      • WordPress.org
      • Documentation
      • Learn WordPress
      • Support
      • Feedback
    • UVM Blogs Home
    • Site Directory
  • Sign In