• Home
  • About
  • Explore
  • Faves
  • Primer
  • Resistance
  • Who

immanence

ecoculture, geophilosophy, mediapolitics

Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Process-relational theory primer

November 5, 2010 by Adrian J Ivakhiv

One of the tasks of this blog, since its inception in late 2008, has been to articulate a theoretical-philosophical perspective that I have come to call “process-relational.” This is a theoretical paradigm and an ontology that takes the basic nature of the world to be that of relational process: that is, it understands the basic constituents of the world to be events of encounter, acts or moments of experience that are woven together to constitute the processes by which all things occur, unfold, and evolve. Understanding ourselves and our relations with the world around us in this way, it is argued, can help us unwind ourselves from out of a set of dualisms that have ensnared modern thought over the last few centuries. In contrast to materialist, idealist, dualist, and other perspectives that have dominated modern western philosophy, a process-relational perspective more explicitly recognizes the dynamic, complex, systemic, and evolving nature of reality.

What follows is a brief summary of the process-relational perspective. It is followed by some bibliographic starting points and by a list of links to some of the more substantive posts on this blog that have dealt with process-relational theory.

Note: An updated and much more complete version of this primer is found in Appendix 1 of Shadowing the Anthropocene, available for free (or pay-what-you-can) download from the publisher.

What is process-relational thought?

Process-relational thought is a form of metaphysical realism that can be found articulated in a variety of philosophies around the world, from ancient times to modern: in Heraclitus and the later Hellenistic Stoics, in Nagarjuna and the Madhyamika philosophers of India, in Zhuang Zhu and the T’ian-t’ai and Hua-Yen Buddhists in China, in the Zen Buddhism of Dogen and the later Zen-inspired Kyoto School of Japanese philosophy, but also, in one form or another, in such western philosophers as Giordano Bruno, Baruch Spinoza, Gottfried Leibniz, Friedrich Schelling, Henri Bergson, Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, John Dewey, Alfred North Whitehead, Wilmon Sheldon, Wilfrid Sellars, Justus Buchler, Charles Hartshorne, Gregory Bateson, Gilbert Simondon, Cornelius Castoriadis, Gilles Deleuze, and Felix Guattari. Contemporary thinkers working in a process-relational vein include Nicholas Rescher, Richard Neville, Robert Corrington, John Deely, David Ray Griffin, Michel Serres, Bruno Latour, Isabelle Stengers, Xavier Zubiri, William Connolly, Catherine Keller, Brian Massumi, Manuel DeLanda, John Protevi, Freya Mathews, Roland Faber, Michael Weber, and Jane Bennett. Process-relational thought also characterizes significant aspects of the thought of G. W. F. Hegel, Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzsche, and Martin Heidegger, and of many who follow in the wake of these influential giants of modern philosophy.

In a more general sense, process-relational themes can be found scattered across a range of intellectual and artistic traditions including those of European and North American Romanticism and Transcendentalism (as in the art and thought of Coleridge, Goethe, Emerson, and Muir); a variety of African and indigenous philosophies; the writings of mystics and spiritual philosophers from Plotinus and Shankara to Jelaluddin Rumi, Jakob Boehme, Sri Aurobindo Ghose, Carl Jung, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, and others; and much of what falls into the Buddhist, Daoist, and neo-Confucian traditions of South and East Asia (sometimes collectively referred to as “Asian field theories”). Such themes are also deeply influential in recent post-constructivist and “non-representational” scholarship in the social and cognitive sciences, including in actor-network theory (Bruno Latour, John Law), enactive cognitivism (Francesco Varela, Evan Thompson), developmental biology (Susan Oyama), ethology and biosemiotics (Jakob von Uexkull, Thomas Sebeok, Jesper Hoffmeyer), and relational and non-representational geography (David Harvey, Doreen Massey, Nigel Thrift, Sarah Whatmore, Steve Hinchliffe); in the speculations of theoretical physicists and biologists including David Bohm, Ilya Prigogine, Brian Goodwin, and Stuart Kauffman; and in East-West philosophical “fusions” like the “integral theory” of Ken Wilber and western variations of Asian nondualist philosophies (such as the work of David Loy, Herbert Guenther, and others).

While not often articulated as a single, unified tradition, a set of common themes justify its identification as an alternative to two forms of thought that have become dominant in western philosophy. These rival traditions are materialism, which views matter as fundamental and human consciousness or perception as a by-product or “epiphenomenon” arising out of material relations, and idealism, which takes perception, consciousness, thought, spirit, or some other non-material force as fundamental and material relations as secondary, if not illusory. A range of interactive and dialectical philosophies have been proposed to mediate between the material and the ideal, but many of these presume the underpinning of a relatively closed binary structure of one kind or another, such as matter versus spirit, idea, or mind, or, alternatively, a conception of opposites, such as Yin and Yang, in which homeostatic balance rather than evolutionary change is considered the baseline norm. Process-relational thought, by contrast, focuses on the dynamism by which things are perpetually moving forward, interacting, and creating new conditions in the world. Process-relational thought rejects the Cartesian idea that there are minds, or things that think, and bodies, or matter that only acts according to strict causal laws. Rather, the two are considered one and the same, or two aspects of the same evolving, processual reality. In this sense, process-relational views are related to certain forms of panpsychism and pan-experientialism, that is, to philosophies that understand “mind” or “mental experience” to be not the possession of specific objects or subjects, but part of the relational expression or manifestation of all things.

At the core of process-relational thought is a focus on the world-making creativity of things: on how things become rather than what they are, on emergence rather than structure. According to this understanding, the world is dynamic and always in process. As Søren Brier puts it, describing the ontology of C. S. Peirce, reality is a spontaneously dynamic “hyper-complexity of living feeling with the tendency to form habits.” That is to say that reality is emergent, evolutionary, and creative –- a view that, not coincidentally, finds much resonance with twentieth-century developments in physics and biology including quantum mechanics, ecology, and chaos and complexity theories. This reality is constituted, at its core, not by objects, permanent structures, material substances, cognitive representations, or Platonic ideas or essences, but by relational encounters and events.

The term “process-relational” is most closely associated with the metaphysics developed by philosopher Alfred North Whitehead, and Whitehead’s influence on contemporary process-relational thought is undeniable. But so are the influences of others mentioned including, especially in recent thinking, the ideas of Henri Bergson, Gilles Deleuze, and C. S. Peirce. All of these philosophers (though less frequently Deleuze) are sometimes included in the broader category of “process philosophers,” but this term alone does not adequately capture the centrality of relations in process-relational ontology. Similarly, the term “relationalism,” frequently understood to be opposed to various kinds of atomism, individualism, “essentialism,” and to recent “object-oriented” philosophies (such as those of Graham Harman and Levi Bryant, “speculative realists” frequently discussed on this blog), fails to adequately emphasize the processual nature of any and all relations. “Process-relationalism” is thus intended to highlight the temporal dynamism, emergent relational systematicity, and inherently creative openness of a living universe composed of interactive events characterized by some measure of perception, responsiveness, “mind,” or subjectivity (or subjectivation). What the different kinds of processes are that characterize and make up the world (as examined, for instance, in DeLanda’s work on meshworks and hierarchies, Wilber’s work on holons and holarchies, etc.), and what the implications of a process-relational view may be for ethics and politics, are among the questions debated by contemporary process-relational thinkers.

Bibliographic starting points

For general accounts of process-relational themes, see Nicholas Rescher, Process Metaphysics: An Introduction to Process Philosophy (Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 1996); Rescher, Process Philosophy: A Survey of Basic Issues (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2000); Rescher, “The Promise of Process Philosophy,” in Columbia Companion to Twentieth-Century Philosophies, ed. C. V. Boundas (New York: Columbia University Press, 2007), pp. 143-155; Douglas Browning and William T. Myers, Philosophers of Process (Fordham University Press, 1998); and David Ray Griffin, Founders of Constructive Postmodern Philosophy: Peirce, James, Bergson, Whitehead, and Hartshorne (SUNY Press, 1993).

Whitehead’s metaphysics are the ones most commonly referred to as “process-relational”; see especially his magnum opus Process and Reality: An Essay in Cosmology (Free Press, 1978) and the more elegant synopsis found in Part Three of Adventures of Ideas (Free Press, 1967). C. Robert Mesle’s Process-Relational Philosophy: An Introduction to Alfred North Whitehead (Templeton Foundation Press, 2008), while an oversimplified introduction to his thought, makes clear why the term is appropriate.

For examples of the evolving dialogue among the different positions within process-relational theory, see Keith Robinson, ed., Deleuze, Whitehead, Bergson: Rhizomatic Connections (Palgrave Macmillan, 2008); Roland Faber (ed.), Secrets of Becoming: Negotiating Whitehead, Deleuze, and Butler (Fordham University Press, 2010); Michel Weber (Ed.), After Whitehead: Rescher on Process Metaphysics (Frankfurt, Germany: Ontos Verlag, 2004); Catherine Keller and Anne Daniell, Process and Difference: Between Cosmological and Poststructuralist Postmodernisms (SUNY Press, 2002); and Steven Shaviro, Without Criteria: Kant, Whitehead, Deleuze, and Aesthetics (MIT Press, 2009). Comparative studies of process philosophy and Buddhist thought include Steve Odin, Process Metaphysics and Hua-yen Buddhism: A Critical Study of Cumulative Penetration vs. Interpenetration (SUNY Press, 1984), and Peter P. Kakol, Emptiness and Becoming: Integrating Madhyamika Buddhism and Process Philosophy (Emerging Perceptions in Buddhist Studies vol. 22; Delhi, India: D. K. Printworld, 2009).

Process-relational theory continues to evolve in dialogue with various forms of speculative realism, panpsychism, “new materialism,” network and complexity theories, and related trends in processual and relational thought. Recent contributions to a process-relational perspective include significant writings by David Ray Griffin, Catherine Keller, Manuel DeLanda, Stuart Kauffman, John Protevi, Michael Weber, Gordon Globus, Tor Hernes, Jane Bennett, William Connolly, Steven Shaviro, Ken Wilber, and Christopher Vitale.

Process-relational theory on this blog

Some posts on this blog that have dealt with process-relational theory include the following, listed in roughly chronological order. Many, though not all, of these refer to the debate between relational and object-oriented ontologies (mentioned above). Please also see the links under “Process-Relational Theory 101” in the blog’s “Primer” page.

    • Harman’s object-oriented philosophizing
    • Things slip away: on Harman’s Latourian object lessons (pt. 2 of 2)
    • Žižek and his Others
    • The politics of objects & relations
    • Bryant’s objects and a possible object/subjectology
    • Aesthetics & Peirce in the Santa Monica Mountains
    • Space junk & the (relational) Real
    • Subjects & objects, together or apart…
    • Cane toads on Mars, firewalls on Pluto
    • Subverting the subversives?
    • The relational seduction of (and between) objects
    • Between Whitehead & Peirce
    • Peirce-Whitehead-Hartshorne & process-relational ontology
    • Actual occasions
    • Being knowing, knowing being
    • Relationalism, Earth jazz, & the solstice
    • Almost a real Paris
    • In defense of relations (again)
    • Strange strangers, or just weird friends?
    • Assemblages, species, genres, & cinemas
    • Buddhist objects & processes
    • The attractions of process (metaphysics)
    • (s)Speculative (r)Realism & philosophy-as-life
    • Ecosophy-G
    • Slice of time
    • The idea of Nature, refigured
    • What a bodymind can do, pt. 1 (of 3)
    • Whitehead’s return, ecology’s boon
    • For the moment
    • Zizek v. Buddhism: who’s the subject?
    • On the subject(s) of experience
    • How a film becomes a subject
    • The conceptual machine
    • What’s real
    • Lava lampy Whitehead?
  • “Beatnik Brothers” in Parrhesia

This post updated on May 19, 2011. Links updated July 5, 2017.

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • More
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Related

Related posts:

  1. Shadowing unshadowed
  2. Harman’s object-oriented philosophizing
  3. conversions & convertibles
  4. “Beatnik Brothers” in Parrhesia
  5. Whitehead’s return, ecology’s boon
  6. Things slip away… (on Harman’s Latourian object lessons)
  7. cane toads on Mars, firewalls on Pluto
  8. the politics of objects & relations

Posted in Eco-theory, Philosophy, Process-relational thought | Tagged Deleuze, metaphysics, object-oriented philosophy, Ontology, epistemology, process philosophy, speculative realism, Whitehead | 14 Comments

14 Responses

  1. on November 5, 2010 at 10:06 am kai

    sorry, but I don’t think ANYONE considers david harvey to adhere to some kind of non-representational theory


  2. on November 5, 2010 at 2:01 pm michael-

    Kai,

    In brief, what do you consider a non-representational view? Is it necessarily opposed to post-constructivist views?

    Just wondering.


  3. on November 5, 2010 at 3:49 pm Adrian

    Kai – I agree with you that Harvey isn’t a non-representationalist in the sense that Nigel Thrift defines the term. But I would say he’s a Marxian dialectical materialist with strong process-relational leanings (very much in evidence, say, in “Justice, Nature, and the Geography of Difference”). I don’t find Thrift’s term very useful in the long run (i.e. aside from serving as a call for a shift in focus), since it would seem to rule out approaches that recognize that representations, signs, etc., are a significant part of the universe. The point is to find out what roles they play.

    “Post-constructivism” is similar, really – it’s the kind of term that, like a carton of eggs, comes with its own “best before” date (and starts to smell when it’s been sitting around too long). Process-relational approaches are constructivist, just not strictly social constructivist, and they’re representational to the extent that they recognize that representations (and signs in general) are part of the communicativity of the universe.


  4. on November 6, 2010 at 2:50 pm Mark Crosby

    Hi Adrian. Thanks for your previous recommendation of Peter Paul Kakol’s EMPTINESS AND BECOMING: INTEGRATING MADHYAMIKA BUDDHISM AND PROCESS PHILOSOPHY (extraordinarily clear writing !)

    I’d ignorantly dismissed Hartshorne in a previous comment here, but now I’m hooked! If any Logic can trump Peirce’s it’s Hartshorne’s.

    I’ve found a vein of good references cached by Google from Religion Online, such as Manley Thompson’s “Hartshorne and Peirce: Individuals and Continuity” (with Hartshorne’s response).

    Maybe the following sums up the relevance for process-relational philosophy. The quotes are from Donald Wayne Viney’s “Philosophy After Hartshorne”:

    “Each [object] responds to (prehends) a world of dynamic singulars that have already come to be and each helps create the world to which subsequent dynamic singulars will respond”.

    Who would argue with that? It’s the next implication Hartshorne draws that still bothers me. (Viney again:)

    “All localized order, however, presupposes a cosmic order that none of the dynamic singulars, individually or in concert, creates. Therefore, order on a cosmic scale can only be explained by an ordering power whose influence is universal or cosmic in scope”.

    Looking forward to the new blog. Even the Sindar had to leave Lothlorien behind..

    Best, Mark


  5. on November 7, 2010 at 4:29 pm Adrian

    Hi Mark – Yes, Kakol is a great example of lucid, coherent, synthetic, critical thinking.

    There’s definitely a lot worth digging into in Hartshorne, though I (like you) am not quite sure what I think of his overall project yet.

    Cheers, Adrian


  6. on November 8, 2010 at 3:26 pm Tom Sparrow

    Adrian,

    I just want to say that this is really helpful, and I’m glad to have heard about your project. You and I will have much to talk about in the future, as this is very close to one of my nascent projects.


  7. on November 9, 2010 at 1:16 pm Tim Morton

    Brilliant Adrian. I shall use this in my next grad class. You’re a star for putting it up here.


  8. on November 9, 2010 at 9:35 pm Mark Crosby

    Adrian, I’m wondering how ECOLOGIES OF THE MOVING IMAGE is, uh, moving along?

    I was reminded of this today by reading Quentin Meillassoux’s “Subtraction and Contraction: Deleuze, Immanence, and MATTER AND MEMORY” (just made available by URBANOMIC from COLLAPSE III (see link at SPECULATIVE HERESY)). Reminded because, on p76, QM begins to come across like the Lacanian Peter Canning in “The Imagination of Immanence” (in the 2000 volume, THE BRAIN IS THE SCREEN, edited by Gregory Flaxman). Reminded, also, because QM dedicates his COLLAPSE essay to Francois Zourabichvili, who contributed another essay to Flaxman’s volume that riled me a decade ago: “The Eye of Montage: Dziga Vertoc and Bergsonian Materialism”. With just time to reread Z’s opening paragraphs, it’s clear that QM is channeling him in the COLLAPSE essay..

    Anyway, maybe your book will be the long-sought antidote to some of the dominant perspectives of THE BRAIN IS THE SCREEN!


  9. on November 10, 2010 at 9:26 am Adrian

    Mark – EMI is moving along well, though it’s behind schedule. It’s about 85% written, with only the last two chapters still somewhat in motion. I’m teaching it in my film class (which is called ‘Ecopolitics & the Cinema’, though it’s unofficially become ‘Ecophilosophy & the Cinema’) and reworking/revising bits & pieces as I go – which means the argument is getting stronger & more lucid and I’m feeling quite good about it. I expect a finished draft will be done before the new year. I’ll probably post bits & pieces at some point, with links to films. Just can’t decide if I should go for theoretical bits & pieces (which have to be taken in large chunks in order to make sense) or critical/analytical ones (which won’t make much sense without the theory).

    I do hope it becomes the antidote to something, and maybe to a lot. I liked Brain is the Screen on the whole (though it’s uneven) more so than some of the other, more schizoanalytic post-Deleuzian cinema stuff. I see it as aligned with Sean Cubitt’s and John Mullarkey’s writing on film, and as the first effort I know of to spin Whitehead into cinema studies/philosophy (to some degree at least). My take on Peirce is distinctly different from Deleuze’s, so the Deleuzianism is more implicit and ‘of the spirit’ than ‘of the letter.’ Anyway, thanks for asking.

    And thanks, Tom, Tim, et al, for the links & appreciation.


  10. on January 28, 2011 at 5:08 am Theory: process-relational etc « Wake_65 Blog

    […]   Leave a comment Yesterday, I was reading Adrian Ivakhiv’s excellent post, process-relational theory primer, as I begin to structure my post-Wake […]


  11. on February 14, 2011 at 1:30 am Lähteitä prosessifilosofiaan ja (kriittiseen) eläintutkimukseen « Uusi akvaario

    […] Adrian Ivakhiv on koonnut blogiinsa prosessien ja suhteiden filosofiaan (process-relational philosophy) liittyvää bibliografiaa ja oheen jonkinlaista pientä ohjelmaluonnosta, täällä. […]


  12. on April 6, 2012 at 3:11 pm Quora

    What is process relational philosophy?…

    I will preface this with telling you that I don’t think this can be answered sufficiently here, and that I have no particular expertise in this field other than the fact that my grandfather, a Christian education professor and Episcopal priest, was wh…


  13. on September 27, 2026 at 11:49 pm Derek Li

    Really enjoyed this synthesis, especially the point that process-relational thought treats “mind” as an expression of relational activity rather than a property confined to a single subject. It reframes creativity as something that emerges out of ongoing exchange between an entity and its environment, rather than a fixed trait one either has or lacks. Curious whether you see Deleuze’s account of difference-in-itself as compatible with Whitehead’s actual occasions, or more of a departure from it?


    • on September 28, 2026 at 12:51 am Adrian J Ivakhiv

      Thanks for the question. I see Deleuze as informed by Whitehead, but developing a similar insight through a rather different conceptual system.



Comments are closed.

  • Categories

    • Academe (108)
    • Anthropocene (79)
    • Blog stuff (53)
    • Cinema (89)
    • Climate change (77)
    • Cultural politics (47)
    • Eco-culture (179)
    • Eco-theory (59)
    • Manifestos & auguries (46)
    • Media ecology (130)
    • Music & soundscape (39)
    • Philosophy (265)
    • Politics (178)
    • Process-relational thought (104)
    • Science & society (39)
    • Spirit matter (135)
    • Uncategorized (66)
    • Visual culture (90)
  • Archives

  • Subscribe2


     

  • Popular resources

    Trump 2.0 critical resource list

    Indigenous identity in Vermont: resources

    Lyme disease & beyond: a bibliographic resource

    Humming the New Earth (on the "global Hum")

    33⅓ Environmental Studies greats (or, a canon revisited) (2015)

    Process-relational theory primer

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2020

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2010

    Between Continental and environmental philosophy (2009)

  • Publications

    Terra Invicta: Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth

    The New Lives of Images: Digital Ecologies & Anthropocene Imaginaries in More-than-Human Worlds

    Routledge Handbook of Ecomedia Studies

    Shadowing the Anthropocene: Eco-Realism for Turbulent Times

    Ecologies of the Moving Image: Cinema, Affect, Nature

    Claiming Sacred Ground: Pilgrims and Politics at Glastonbury and Sedona

    Academia.edu (various articles; requires registration)

  • Selected talks & interviews

    Terra Invicta book launch, U. Tallinn, 2025

    Ecologies of the Multipolar Information Disorder, SFU, 2025

    Apocalyptic Anxieties, SFU, 2023

    Toward the Symbiocene talk, 2023 (good first stop!)

    SFU Global Humanities interview

    KCSB Selectric Davyland interview

    The Zone is Us (Vermont Humanities, 2022)

    Krista Tippett On Being (Speaking of Faith) interview

    Imperfect Buddha podcast

    More links here

  • Music

    Bandcamp music page

    What's on my Bandcamp music page

    Soundcloud playlist (music sampler)

    "As Pluto Descends" trilogy

    10 greatest albums of the 'album era'
  • Associated sites

    Terrestri(e)alism

    EcoCultureLab: Enter the Feverish World

    EcoCultureLab blog

    Media+Environment journal

    M+E+ blog

    UKR-TAZ: A Ukrainian Temporary Autonomous Zone

  • This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States license.
  • wordpress visitors

Get a free blog at WordPress.com

Theme: Mistylook by Sadish.


Skip to toolbar
  • UVM Blogs
    • WordPress
      • About WordPress
      • Get Involved
      • WordPress.org
      • Documentation
      • Learn WordPress
      • Support
      • Feedback
    • UVM Blogs Home
    • Site Directory
  • Sign In