• Home
  • About
  • Explore
  • Faves
  • Primer
  • Resistance
  • Who

immanence

ecoculture, geophilosophy, mediapolitics

Feeds:
Posts
Comments

in defense of relations (again)

August 21, 2010 by Adrian J Ivakhiv

In response to my last post, Levi is arguing, as Graham has before, that relational ontologies have had their day, that “it is relational and processual thought that has become a habit that prevents us from thinking, not object-oriented thought,” and that “For the last century we’ve repeatedly said ‘things are related’ to such a degree that claims about interdependence, relation, and interconnection have lost a good deal of meaning” and “become stale metaphors and worn coins.” He continues:

“Rather than beginning with relation, context, interdependence, interconnection, etc., what would we learn if we instead thought of autonomous objects perpetually shifting and jumping between relations? My wager is that this would teach us a great deal more in the ecological framework than endless talk of holism and relation. We would begin to ask how substances perturb networks, rather than treating networks as static and fixed systems where all is harmonious and balanced as we tend to do now.”

It’s true that there is a popular view of ecology as positing systems that are, ideally, “harmonious and balanced.” (We might call this the Disney Lion King version of reality.) Ecologists themselves used to speak about certain kinds of networks (ecosystemic “climax communities”) that way in the 1920s and 1930s, and in some cases up to the 1960s or so. Some environmentalists still use those tropes on occasion today. But if everything actually was “harmonious and balanced,” would there be any need for environmentalism at all, since there’d be no need to concern oneself with re-establishing some modicum of “harmony and balance”?


In his previous email, Levi defends objects and substances on political grounds:

Now what follows, in relation to this noble [ethical/political] concern, if you’re an ontological relationist? Well, you certainly can’t theorize any movement beyond oppression or domination. Why? Think it through. Because the object that shifts relations is an entirely different object [my emphasis – ai]. Thereby nothing has been liberated. Rather, we’ve simply gotten a new object. This doesn’t seem too reassuring. What is needed is objects that are mobile and nomadic, objects that enter into relations, while always remaining irreducible to their relations. That, I believe, is what OOO articulates.

But, in itself, how new and different is this? Hasn’t our society institutionalized the presumption that people are, first and foremost, individuals, though they may link up into groups, societies, cultures, corporations, and the like, and that objects are distinct objects (belonging to those people) first and participate in ecological processes only secondarily (if at all)? I know that Levi’s onticological variant is a highly nuanced and new version of it, but doesn’t this independent-objects-entering-into-relations model practically define the modern Western philosophical tradition?

As for Levi’s description of the process-relational position – that “the object that shifts relations is an entirely different object – why should this be the case? Let’s think about it. If objects are defined by their relations, and if all are processes of one kind or another, as a process-relational view would hold, then what happens to an object that shifts relations? Well, it all depends on how it shifts which relations. One cannot speak of relations as if they are all the same. The equivalent, for an objectologist, would be to claim that all objects are identical. Neither claim is a fair characterization of the other position, and it would be helpful if both sides refrained from claiming it about the opposing side. If objects are particular kinds of relational processes -– the kinds that maintain certain formal properties over time (and over multiple sets of relational “shifts”) –- then objects do not become “completely different objects” unless and until those formal properties change or disintegrate in fundamental ways. They can still change some of their relations without fundamentally altering the overall set of relational processes that (self-)constitute them.

So, for instance, a human being does not become a “completely different object” by eating a new kind of breakfast cereal. (Perhaps it takes such mundane examples to show the absurdity of this kind of claim about relational ontologies.) But a human being may temporarily become a somewhat different object by ingesting a hallucinogenic mushroom. The reason why eating Corn Flakes doesn’t fundamentally change the person (and I have to admit some exasperation in detailing something that seems to me so obvious) is that the cereal only affects a small subset of the processes that make up that human, and they affect it in ways that are readily assimilated into the cycles of those processes. A sacred peyote-ingestion ceremony, on the other hand, has an effect that is much more powerful, affecting a larger subset of the processes constituting that person. But these, too, will go away, with the baseline processes returning completely or in partially (and sometimes significantly) altered forms. It’s all about the nature and character, rhythms and periodicities, apertures, trajectories, etc. of the processes that make up the “object” in question. (Process-relational philosophy prefers not to speak of “objects,” since it’s not clear what’s meant by such abstractions, and because Whitehead, at least, uses that term to mean something more specific; but it can certainly speak of things like humans, peyote plants, storm systems, and so on, because we can easily agree that we know what’s being referred to by these terms.)

Levi seems to be assuming here, as Graham has in the past, that if objects are defined by their relations, then somehow all objects become all relations, with no differentiating between any of them. As Levi wrote here:

Rather than a holistic system in which everything is internally related to everything else in a sort of fixed crystalline structure (or, at least, a structure that only unfolds diachronously according to a synchronously structured system), we instead get fleeting and temporary structures where actors or objects can depart from different regimes of relations and thereby come to manifest very different qualities.

The first part is worded as a critique of “relationism,” but it’s a relationism that sounds too much like old structuralist studies of indigenous cultural mythologies or of films or novels, where it’s assumed that the object is more or less set and bounded (but not that the entire universe is). The second part — “fleeting and temporary structures…” — sounds very much like the kind of description I would call “process-relational.” The rest of Levi’s post does as well:

What if instead the social field is composed of independent actors that move in and out of relations, where relations are constantly reconfiguring themselves, where there is far more freedom than we ever expected. If that’s the case, then suddenly the nature of the question changes significantly. Rather than asking how to escape from a holistic field of interdependent relations, we now ask why any set of relations manages to persist at all (this comes as a surprise insofar as objects are external to their relations). We begin to engage in the world of cartography, analyzing the regimes of attraction that bring about rather stable configurations of actors. And through this cartography we begin to local [locate?] weak links, points of passage, points where change is possible, through the severance of certain relations or the introduction of other actors that might modify the network as a whole. Most importantly, we direct our attention not to a subject, but to the organization of situations. In this way we avoid forms of abstraction that are so focused on Act and Subject that they ignore regimes of attraction playing a constraining role on how actors can manifest themselves. We learn something of the world and perhaps, through that knowledge, acquire the means to change it. [emphasis added]

This is, in my view, process-relational ontology in a nutshell, or at least one variant of it. The emphasized bits sound very much like the sorts of material-discursive poststructuralisms being developed in geography, anthropology, and other fields over the last twenty years, and of course like actor-network theory, which is, after all, a network theory. Latour has himself referred to it as “actant-rhizome theory,” and an actant, as we know, is not an “object” with all the properties an ontologist would assign it, but just something that “could be said to act”; and a rhizome is also not an object but a movement, a relational vector.

It’s obvious to me, then, that Levi’s (and Graham’s) object-oriented ontology is very compatible with the kind of process-relational view that I espouse, differing only in its emphasis and its language. As Levi puts it here, citing Harman, “no matter how many points of view on the object you enumerate, even if they go to infinity and eternity, you will never have an unadulterated access to the object precisely because objects are withdrawn.” The process-relationalist agrees that you will never have unadulterated access to the object, but this is not because (a) there are stable objects that (b) aren’t fully stable after all, because they persistently “withdraw”. It is because that’s the nature of reality: things change, withdrawing and deferring and differentiating themselves as they do. What makes it interesting, for a process-relational ontologist, is less what those things are (being) than the ways that they change and can change (becoming). That goes both for the “withdrawing” object and for any object that would try to “have unadulterated access” to that object.

Instead of positing two steps, then -– (1) more or less stable objects, and (2) the qualification that these objects withdraw — the process-relationist posits a world of different kinds of relational processes in which arising/withdrawing/deferring/differentiation is just what happens, the way of all activity, though it arises and develops in different ways. I like the idea that objects “withdraw” -– it’s part of what confirms OOO’s processualism for me (and why I would like to call it object-relational or, even better, object-deconstructive ontology, object-now-here-and-now-gone ontology). But I don’t agree it necessarily makes it an obviously better approach to a world that is always fundamentally in process.

As for the political questions, I’ll leave it up to others -– especially regular folks not steeped in arcane Continental-philosophical debates –- to decide whether or not we already live in a world where everything is thought of in processual and relational terms (only) and where objects and substances are no longer thought to exist (as seems to be the suggestion in Levi’s post).

* * * * * *

A recap on why process-relational ontology is far from obsolete

My belief, if it needs reiterating, is that we -– society at large -– still have not developed a nuanced enough understanding of the nature of relational process, including the many different kinds of relational processes that make up the world. This is why we still put animals in cages (as if the jaguar in a cage is the same as the jaguar in a forest) and dump toxins on our farms (as if the final product is the pest-free corn and not the health of the soil), still produce objects that are guaranteed to be obsolete junk in a few years (as if their making and disposal wasn’t an integral part of them), still buy those objects (as if they will satisfy our cravings for something new and exciting), still send soldiers to war and forget about them when they come back (leaving their partners and kids without health insurance, as is the case with a friend of ours who lives up the road), still expect that we can “win” wars (as if they won’t breed the resentment that will lead to even worse wars), still define people according to fixed gender identities and racial categories, and put people away for life (in this country at least) because they don’t have the means to live in ways that would exercise their creative potential, and so on and so forth.

As long as our society cannot institutionalize the taking into account of where things come from, where they go, and how actions affect the world, now and generations down the line, we still don’t understand the nature of the world. That world is relational and processual: everything unfolds in and through relational interactions over time. Actions, being relational, bind us together or they separate us. All that there is is action, which means relational exchange and process. We, too, are action, or the capacity for it, which is why we can make change –- and do, inherently, with every act of ours. We create ourselves through these acts, which means we create the relations that constitute us, and relations always involve others. We need to better understand the effects of our actions on others, because the world that is produced through our actions (and theirs) is the only world there is.

Objects that remain separate, on the other hand, and that ultimately withdraw into their own shadowy selves from the open space of encounter, are objects that don’t need to take into account such things. They can presume an independence, a freedom, above and beyond the hazardous fray of lively interaction. Establishing such relative independence is not a bad thing: it’s how a planet like ours protects itself from meteors and ultraviolet rays (through building up a thick atmospheric skin), and how humans have managed to squeeze out the capacity to live lives that are long enough to raise children and grandchildren, to write books and craft dramas, to travel the world and come back home to ponder what we saw. But the urge toward the comforts of that kind of independence can become obsessive, compulsive, and toxic. It is itself a relational act, and it is the kind of act that colonial-imperial culture has used to shield itself from the very relational results of its acts upon others. Of course things withdraw from their relations, or from some relations and toward others -– with oneself, one’s memories and fantasies (in our dream lives), and so on. Everything does that to some extent, and nothing is fully definable, describable, and accountable by its relations — because there’s no one there to fully define it, and even if there’d be such a one, an all-seeing, non-processual God, by the time the defining and accounting came to its conclusion, the thing being defined would have been long gone.

The quality of the relations that make up the world is what counts. I think that process-relational thought is aligned here with feminist theory (in all its forms), with anti-racist and anti-/de-/post-colonial thought, with the Marxist and anarchist critiques of oppressive class structures, with the Mahayana Buddhist vow to “liberate” all beings and the Christian vow to help “the least of our brothers” (and sisters), with the pagan and indigenous sense of respect for the cycles of life, and with the poststructuralist account of the networked, relational flux of ideas and concepts and things in general. Ethically and politically, I have no doubt that our object-oriented friends are plowing the same fields as us, and I respect their desire to start from (ontological) scratch so as to create a distinctly new language for thinking about things and the world. In fact, I find their work fascinating, and find its proponents (certainly Levi and Graham, who are the only ones I’ve read a fair bit of now) to be genuinely brilliant and interdisciplinary wide-ranging thinkers. I greet their work with eagerness, and am grateful for their willingness to tolerate and engage my criticisms.

But I don’t, for a moment, think that the “coin” of processes and relations is “stale” and fully spent. If anything, it hasn’t really been cashed in yet. It may seem familiar from its popular and superficial variants (the “Disney ecology” referred to above, structuralisms and textualist poststructuralisms, and so on), but it hasn’t been developed enough yet along the lines that Whitehead, Peirce, Deleuze, and more recently DeLanda, Protevi, Shaviro, and many others have pointed toward, and that would fully engage with the sciences of cognition and consciousness, complexity and nonlinear dynamics, and the like. Arguing that it’s passé is a rhetorical move that will help OOO get some followers among discontented Continental philosophers, but I don’t think it will get much beyond that particular neighborhood. To the extent that it provides a reasoned defense of the need for a different approach to things, I can understand their resorting to it.

Ultimately I believe we are saying very similar things and just emphasizing different, but more or less complementary, aspects of those things. But it’s a difference that makes enough of a difference for us to keep thinking about it.

(I realize that this has turned into a bit of a rant and that it probably would be easy to pick out select pieces of it to critique. Perhaps that’s what I’ve been doing with others’ words, too. I’ll try to do less of that, recognizing instead that certain subarguments will always remain contentious, especially where terms are being used differently (e.g., my “relationism” may not be Levi’s, his “objects” aren’t mine), but that the broader points of agreement, and a general sense of respect, need to be kept central.)

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • More
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Related

Related posts:

  1. Egypt & everywhere
  2. “clean” coal
  3. More on Harman, or what’s outside the system of relations?
  4. mediation arrives…
  5. Things slip away… (on Harman’s Latourian object lessons)
  6. heat & light
  7. Being knowing, knowing being
  8. Harman’s object-oriented philosophizing

Posted in Philosophy, Process-relational thought | Tagged object-oriented philosophy, Whitehead | 19 Comments

19 Responses

  1. on August 21, 2010 at 9:33 pm skholiast

    Adrian, well said. I think I can understand why the relationist stance would be held to be no longer cutting-edge, but that it should be dismissed as worn-out seems hasty. Yes, there’s a too-easy circle-of-life pseudo-relationism out there, but in fact thinking relationism through is hard, and counter-intuitive (partly because our thinking is noun-oriented (even if our nouns are “process” and “assemblage” and “network”). After all, if one says “relationships” the next question is, “between what?” and before you know it we’re stuck in a kind of hermeneutic circle again. “Not that there’s anything wrong with that,” but this snag has I think been exploited by those who want to say that there’s a blind spot in relationism. I think this blind spot, if that’s what it is, is as essential as the one in the retina, and in any case is matched by the puzzles attendant upon the assertion that objects “withdraw”–an assertion i certainly see as coherent with the OO project and following from its aims and premises, but which still leaves one with residual questions both epistemological (“how do you know?”) and methodological (“what’s the point?”) Understand that I don’t think these are such liabilities that OO approaches are the obvious losers; at the risk of correlationsim, I see this as a sort of Kantian antinomy. (I [try to] resolve it, myself, by recourse to time vs. eternity, but that’s not everyone’s cuppa.) My main point here is to agree with you that reports of relationism’s having outlived its usefulness are premature– but I think there might be some call for saying that defenders of relationism haven’t yet thought through all the difficulties, and indeed some of these may be intractable on the level of discourse. (Nagarjuna certainly seems to have thought so.)


  2. on August 22, 2010 at 12:44 pm Joseph C Goodson

    I am very much enjoying this exchange between you and Levi. There is some great stuff here and you make some very important points. Also, your blog is a sheer pleasure to read with its high and cool contrasts of blue and white. Very sharp!


  3. on August 23, 2010 at 7:45 pm Paul Bains

    I am reading John Deely’s ‘Intentionality and Semiotics: a story of mutual fecondation’ (2007), and I thought his comments on ‘substance’ might be of interest.

    For me it shows how much we have forgotten our precursors. It also makes me more convinced that there is no absolutely withdrawn object, a la G. Harman.

    Levi’s objects are not, it seems, abs withdrawn, just not fully manifesting all at once…

    What follows is Deely’s argument:

    Substances are not ‘absolutely absolute’ but ‘relatively absolute’.

    Substance has a dependency on being in an environmental niche.

    It is the modern notion of substance (typified by Kant) as an absolutely indep (and ultimately unknowable) substrate that ignores this dependency. Only logically does a being exist apart from and prior to its relations; existentially a being depends on its relations.

    “In St Thomas the notion of substance does not have the modern connotation of ‘absolute’, but rather the sense of something having its boundaries as an existing individual, separate from other individuals but not ‘absolutely independent’ of its surroundings. The notion of substance as ‘absoluta’, then, among the Latin Thomistic thinkers – a subjectivity able to maintain itself according to an internal identity, separate from the rest of the physical universe, but not separated’ from that universe, and indeed dependent upon specific parts of the universe external to its body in order to maintain its internal identity over time (and only for a time). – is a notion as compatible with modern notion of organism in biology as the modern conception of substance as a self-sufficient substrate underlying but unaffected by interaction is incompatible”. (p.139)

    “The substance that Aquinas and Poinsot understood from Aristotle, above and before all else, needs to be understood as a unified centre of actions and interactions which is not a ‘part’ of a larger whole in the sense of a whole unified by a single intrinsic principle…but is yet indeed a ‘part’ of a larger whole in the sense of an ecosphere constituted by many distinct forms of life and sustained by their interactions, apart from which neither the individual forms or life nor the ecosphere was a whole would long endure.”(p.140).

    Or as G. Bateson liked to say the unit of survival is organism + environment.

    This is the opposite of Kant in his first published work Thoughts on theTrue Estimation of Living forces, (1749):

    “Since every self-sufficient being contains within itself the complete source of all its determinations, it is not necessary for its existence that it stand in relation to other things. Substances can therefore exist, and yet have no outer relations to things, nor stand in any actual connection with them.”

    What does this remind you of! A very withdrawn being….

    This ‘scholastic’ understanding of substance seems tailor made for ecological thought.

    What I am far from persuaded of is the claim that inanimate objects have intentional relations/objects. In fact, I think it’s extremely unlikely. But that requires a theory of psyche which I won’t even begin to discuss. This post is way to long already.

    Things in themselves are not the problem, for there cannot be many without there being ones, as Aristotle noted. The qualifier ‘unknowable’ is the ‘meaningless surplusage’ (Peirce (CP 5.525).


  4. on August 24, 2010 at 7:15 am Paul Bains

    Just browsing Arg Dot Org and came across this old piece by Varela on ‘The Biology of Intentionality’:

    A short extract…:

    A second, complementary dimension of basic biologic

    that is central to focus our discussion is the

    nature of the relationship between autopoietic autonomous

    unities and their environment. It is exhypothesis

    evident that an autopoietic system depends

    on its physico-chemical mileu for its conservation

    as a separate entity, otherwise it would dissolve

    back into it. Whence the intriguing paradoxicality

    proper to an autonomous identity: the living system

    must distinguish itself from its environment, while

    at the same time maintaining its coupling; this linkage

    cannot be detached since it is against this very

    environment from which the organism arises comes

    forth. Now, in this dialogic coupling between the

    living unity and the physico-chemical environment,

    the balance is slightly weighted towards the living

    since it has the active role in this reciprocal coupling.

    In de ning what it is as unity, in the very

    same movement it de nes what remains exterior to

    it, that is to say, its surrounding environment. A

    closer examination also makes it evident that this

    exteriorization can only be understood, so to speak,

    from the \inside”: the autopoietic unity creates a

    perspective from which the exterior is one, which

    cannot be confused with the physical surroundings

    as they appear to us as observers, the land of physical

    and chemical laws simpliciter, devoid of such

    perspectivism.


  5. on August 24, 2010 at 8:55 pm Adrian

    To Skholiast – Yes, I agree with you that “thinking relationism through” is quite hard work, and that the best we have, for the most part, are indications and incomplete systems (Whitehead’s, Deleuze’s, et al), at least by philosophical standards.

    I don’t think that relational and processual approaches have been given their due in philosophy, in part because the many relationisms that are out there (western, Asian, et al) have hardly been brought together into a coherent conversation, let alone synthesized into a foolproof, leak-proof ontology. Many of those who have tried haven’t necessarily used these terms (relationism, process philosophy), though there are some anthologies and summaries of process philosophy (like Nicholas Rescher’s) that at least establish the existence of the tradition… All of that contributes to my disappointment that well-read philosophers like Harman are so quick to dismiss the whole effort, as if it’s been played out already when it (to me) so clearly hasn’t been.

    And maybe it’s true, as you suggest, that the level of discourse alone will never quite ‘get it’ all. But I think it can point to it (as Nagarjuna and other mystics have all probably known).


  6. on August 24, 2010 at 9:15 pm Adrian

    To Joseph – Thanks for you kind comments. I’ve appreciated your comments on other blogs (despite taking you up on that issue recently on Levi’s).

    To Paul – Thanks for the Deely & Varela quotes. The Deely ones are particularly intriguing! I’ve got a few things of his on my reading list (Four Ages of Understanding being the major one), but I’ve just gone and requested a copy of this book for my campus library (thanks to your recommendation).

    Cheers.

    Adrian


  7. on August 24, 2010 at 9:55 pm Mark Crosby

    As Adrian says, Paul, these quotes were right on target. Any revival of substance and essence needs to take these distinctions into account. And these quotes addressed precisely the questions I had when Graham wrote (8/22 “relationism continued”) that

    “The main problem, I insist, is that the continental philosophy ZEITGEIST still thinks: ‘Rock-hard substance, bad. Silky-smooth contexts and processes, good. Essence, bad and oppressive. Identity as performance, good and liberating”.

    This is certainly NOT a characterization of Adrian’s position. Nor does this describe the attitudes in process-relational thought of the Peirce, Dewey, and Whitehead varieties.

    Even as an amateur, I would dare to suggest another forgotten philosopher who probably had at least some influence on Xavier Zubiri; namely, George Santayana and his REALMS OF BEING: ESSENCE (1927), MATTER (1930), TRUTH (1937), and SPIRIT (1940). If I had the time, I might even compare these to SKY, EARTH, GODS and MORTALS, respectively..

    But, it seems all for naught, since nearly every response from the OO camp seems to be, as Adrian suggests in this post, “a rhetorical move that will help OOO get some followers among discontented Continental philosophers”.


  8. on August 25, 2010 at 4:15 pm Paul Bains

    4 Ages is a big bk!

    New Beginnings is a good intro. The Semiotics and Intentionality bk is challenging as an intro.

    A great book to get the library to buy is Deely’s new “on Purely Objective Reality’

    http://www.degruyter.de/cont/fb/sk/detailEn.cfm?id=IS-9781934078075-1

    He needs to sell 40 copies so that they bring it out in paperback at an accessible price….

    Gotta go for now but the concept of vicarious causality and ‘vicars’ is central to latin scholasticism and the doctrine of the ‘species’ or specifying forms. This is connected with scholastic ‘intentionality’ which has nothing to do with Brentano’s intentionality except the name…Brentano was orig a catholic priest who knew Aquinas’ work well. He takes the term from their but castrates it.


  9. on February 21, 2017 at 2:30 am Minna Falencki

    nice job. That’s exactly what I was looking for.


  10. on January 25, 2018 at 4:19 am Viabol Rx Trial

    I have read so many articles or reviews about the blogger lovers except this article
    is actually a nice post, keep it up.


  11. on January 25, 2018 at 4:47 pm Testosterone T3 Review

    I’m impressed, I must say. Rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative and engaging, and
    without a doubt, you’ve hit the nail on the head.
    The problem is something that too few people are speaking intelligently about.
    I’m very happy I found this in my hunt for something relating to this.


  12. on February 5, 2018 at 4:42 pm Volidian Cream

    Aw, this was an incredibly nice post. Taking a few minutes and
    actual effort to make a good article… but what can I say…

    I put things off a whole lot and don’t manage to get nearly anything done.


  13. on February 5, 2018 at 5:30 pm Supreme Choice CBD Oil Review

    I’d been honored to get a call from my friend immediately he identified the important recommendations shared on the
    site. Studying your blog publication is a real brilliant
    experience. Thanks again for taking into consideration readers at all like me, and I
    desire for you the best of achievements as being a professional in this field.


  14. on February 8, 2018 at 10:45 pm Avila Skincare

    Hello.This post was extremely remarkable, especially since I was
    browsing for thoughts on this matter last Saturday.


  15. on February 11, 2018 at 4:15 am Cleanse Slim Xt

    It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this fantastic
    blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your
    RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates
    and will talk about this website with my Facebook group.

    Talk soon!


  16. on February 19, 2018 at 6:51 am TryVix Cream

    Very instructive and superb body structure of subject matter, now that’s user genial (:.


  17. on February 21, 2018 at 9:31 pm Pure Cleanse Ultra Review

    Hiya, I’m really glad I’ve found this information. Today bloggers publish only about gossips
    and web and this is actually irritating. A good site
    with interesting content, that is what I need.
    Thanks for keeping this site, I’ll be visiting it.

    Do you do newsletters? Can not find it.


  18. on February 23, 2018 at 2:24 am Enjoyllery Facial Serum

    Hi, its nice post about media print, we all be familiar with media is
    a wonderful source of information.


  19. on February 23, 2018 at 1:36 pm UltraSlim Pure Cleanse

    I simply desired to thank you so much once more. I am not sure the
    things I might have carried out in the absence of the entire hints provided
    by you on my question. Previously it was an absolute frustrating
    case in my circumstances, nevertheless encountering the professional tactic
    you managed that made me to jump over fulfillment.
    Now i am grateful for your help and in addition expect
    you recognize what an amazing job that you are putting in educating
    other individuals through your web site. Most probably you have never come across all
    of us.



Comments are closed.

  • Categories

    • Academe (108)
    • Anthropocene (79)
    • Blog stuff (53)
    • Cinema (89)
    • Climate change (77)
    • Cultural politics (47)
    • Eco-culture (179)
    • Eco-theory (59)
    • Manifestos & auguries (46)
    • Media ecology (130)
    • Music & soundscape (39)
    • Philosophy (265)
    • Politics (178)
    • Process-relational thought (104)
    • Science & society (39)
    • Spirit matter (135)
    • Uncategorized (66)
    • Visual culture (90)
  • Archives

  • Subscribe2


     

  • Popular resources

    Trump 2.0 critical resource list

    Indigenous identity in Vermont: resources

    Lyme disease & beyond: a bibliographic resource

    Humming the New Earth (on the "global Hum")

    33⅓ Environmental Studies greats (or, a canon revisited) (2015)

    Process-relational theory primer

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2020

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2010

    Between Continental and environmental philosophy (2009)

  • Publications

    Terra Invicta: Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth

    The New Lives of Images: Digital Ecologies & Anthropocene Imaginaries in More-than-Human Worlds

    Routledge Handbook of Ecomedia Studies

    Shadowing the Anthropocene: Eco-Realism for Turbulent Times

    Ecologies of the Moving Image: Cinema, Affect, Nature

    Claiming Sacred Ground: Pilgrims and Politics at Glastonbury and Sedona

    Academia.edu (various articles; requires registration)

  • Selected talks & interviews

    Terra Invicta book launch, U. Tallinn, 2025

    Ecologies of the Multipolar Information Disorder, SFU, 2025

    Apocalyptic Anxieties, SFU, 2023

    Toward the Symbiocene talk, 2023 (good first stop!)

    SFU Global Humanities interview

    KCSB Selectric Davyland interview

    The Zone is Us (Vermont Humanities, 2022)

    Krista Tippett On Being (Speaking of Faith) interview

    Imperfect Buddha podcast

    More links here

  • Music

    Bandcamp music page

    What's on my Bandcamp music page

    Soundcloud playlist (music sampler)

    "As Pluto Descends" trilogy

    10 greatest albums of the 'album era'
  • Associated sites

    Terrestri(e)alism

    EcoCultureLab: Enter the Feverish World

    EcoCultureLab blog

    Media+Environment journal

    M+E+ blog

    UKR-TAZ: A Ukrainian Temporary Autonomous Zone

  • This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States license.
  • wordpress visitors

Get a free blog at WordPress.com

Theme: Mistylook by Sadish.


Skip to toolbar
  • UVM Blogs
    • WordPress
      • About WordPress
      • Get Involved
      • WordPress.org
      • Documentation
      • Learn WordPress
      • Support
      • Feedback
    • UVM Blogs Home
    • Site Directory
  • Sign In