• Home
  • About
  • Explore
  • Faves
  • Primer
  • Resistance
  • Who

immanence

ecoculture, geophilosophy, mediapolitics

Feeds:
Posts
Comments

secret language (of scientists) going public

January 3, 2010 by Adrian J Ivakhiv

At a time when so many social mammal species are in crisis, it’s at least heartening to see news like tonight’s 60 Minutes segment on “The Secret Language of Elephants” or today’s Times Online article “Scientists say dolphins should be treated as ‘non-human persons’.” The scientific taboo on anthropomorphism is finally lifting, and animal behavior studies are becoming more like anthropology — something that only lone rogue anthros like John Lilly or Barbara Noske would have dared call for not too long ago…

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • More
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Related

Related posts:

  1. Moving Environments: Affect, Emotion, & Ecocinema (live blog?)
  2. What are the humanities? (Two cultures, redux)
  3. Eco-onto-politics 2: Integralism & climate change
  4. The tree of life, in pieces
  5. McKibben & the frontlines of war
  6. May Day thoughts: on labor & livelihood
  7. Spreading revolution
  8. Moving Environments, Day 1

Posted in Eco-culture | Tagged animals | 8 Comments

8 Responses

  1. on January 4, 2010 at 5:07 am johan

    Dolphins say scientists should be treated as ‘impersonal humans’


  2. on January 4, 2010 at 9:56 am Gavan Watson

    A nice move and a good beginning, no doubt; engaging ethically with these organisms is very important. I do have problems with simply expanding concepts of personhood outwards from us as a centre—we include dolphins & the great apes because they are like us.

    What about the organisms that escape our ability to capture or understand their intelligence? Ethical engagement with the non-human might need a more multi-centric approach.


  3. on January 4, 2010 at 6:00 pm kvond

    I’m trying to track down the titular ethics claim for dolphin person rights, and its sees to lie in this:

    “Thomas White, professor of ethics at Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles, who has written a series of academic studies suggesting dolphins should have rights, will speak at the same conference.

    “Thomas White, professor of ethics at Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles, who has written a series of academic studies suggesting dolphins should have rights, will speak at the same conference.

    The scientific research . . . suggests that dolphins are ‘non-human persons’ who qualify for moral standing as individuals,” he said.”

    If anyone has a copy of any of these ethics studies of Thomas White, please email them to me at kvdi@earthlink.net , if I can ask.


  4. on January 4, 2010 at 7:49 pm adrian

    kvond – The article suggests several comparative standards for assessing moral considerability of an organism, including its ‘intelligence’ (‘higher’, ‘more complex’), its brain size relative to body mass, its possession of ‘culture,’ etc. White is an ethicist and author of In Defense of Dolphins: The New Moral Frontier (Blackwell), among other books. An overview of that book is here. I’m not familiar with his arguments (beyond scanning this piece), but the animal ethics/liberation literature includes arguments from a broad range of positions from Kantians and utilitarians to feminists, phenomenologists, Deleuzians, et al. There’s certainly room for more Spinozan insights…

    Gavan – Your suggestion dovetails well with Anthony Weston’s multicentrist ethics manifesto, a version of which appears here.

    Johan – I like your implicit suggestion that dolphins might acknowledge a difference between scientific “impersonality” and the (presumably more normal) human capacity for empathy, etc. The struggle for a more compassionate science has been waged both in popular culture (where both Dr. Frankenstein scientists and the Jane Goodalls and Dian Fosseys of the world are both well known) and in science itself (by cognitive ethologists like Marc Bekoff and others). I cheer when I see signs that the scientific norm is changing for the better.


  5. on January 5, 2010 at 2:16 pm kvond

    Yes, Adrian, I could guess at all the arguments towards “personhood” for instance a kind of criteria listing. It is only that the use of “person” is a particular kind of distinction, and I am curious how it is handled. From a Spinozist point of view and assertion of “right” would not rely upon the notion of personhood, I would have to say, since right is anything that you have the power to do, and moral obligation comes from simply sharing powers of freedom to a maximal limit. I’ll check out his book.


  6. on January 9, 2010 at 12:51 pm Smelly Brain

    First we try to understand animals in a way that we are better suitable to kill them later on? The past has learned us that we are not so careful in taking care for animals that are almost extinct. It would be best if scientists would never publish anything they find out because the wrong people will always take profit from it.


  7. on March 15, 2010 at 11:50 am Daphne

    But Adrian, is the taboo lifting on anthropomorphism a good thing? Isn’t it a little self-absorbed to think that personhood is appropriate or even desired by non-humans?


  8. on March 15, 2010 at 12:17 pm adrian

    Daphne – ‘Personhood’ is a complex social idea, one that gets negotiated differently in different societies. All social animals relate to (at least some) social animals socially, which means according to certain behavioral habits and rules that are understood to apply to social relations. (Think of wolves in a wolf pack, cats in your neighborhood, etc.)

    The scientific taboo against anthropomorphism has been too heavy-handed, and one of its effects has been to make it difficult to recognize commonalities between humans and nonhumans. Lifting that taboo doesn’t mean that we see other species as identical to us in every way (personhood, the right to vote, etc.); it just means that we can be more attuned to differences *and* similarities.



Comments are closed.

  • Categories

    • Academe (108)
    • Anthropocene (79)
    • Blog stuff (53)
    • Cinema (89)
    • Climate change (77)
    • Cultural politics (47)
    • Eco-culture (179)
    • Eco-theory (59)
    • Manifestos & auguries (46)
    • Media ecology (130)
    • Music & soundscape (39)
    • Philosophy (265)
    • Politics (178)
    • Process-relational thought (104)
    • Science & society (39)
    • Spirit matter (135)
    • Uncategorized (66)
    • Visual culture (90)
  • Archives

  • Subscribe2


     

  • Popular resources

    Trump 2.0 critical resource list

    Indigenous identity in Vermont: resources

    Lyme disease & beyond: a bibliographic resource

    Humming the New Earth (on the "global Hum")

    33⅓ Environmental Studies greats (or, a canon revisited) (2015)

    Process-relational theory primer

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2020

    Books of the decade in ecocultural theory, 2010

    Between Continental and environmental philosophy (2009)

  • Publications

    Terra Invicta: Ukrainian Wartime Reimaginings for a Habitable Earth

    The New Lives of Images: Digital Ecologies & Anthropocene Imaginaries in More-than-Human Worlds

    Routledge Handbook of Ecomedia Studies

    Shadowing the Anthropocene: Eco-Realism for Turbulent Times

    Ecologies of the Moving Image: Cinema, Affect, Nature

    Claiming Sacred Ground: Pilgrims and Politics at Glastonbury and Sedona

    Academia.edu (various articles; requires registration)

  • Selected talks & interviews

    Terra Invicta book launch, U. Tallinn, 2025

    Ecologies of the Multipolar Information Disorder, SFU, 2025

    Apocalyptic Anxieties, SFU, 2023

    Toward the Symbiocene talk, 2023 (good first stop!)

    SFU Global Humanities interview

    KCSB Selectric Davyland interview

    The Zone is Us (Vermont Humanities, 2022)

    Krista Tippett On Being (Speaking of Faith) interview

    Imperfect Buddha podcast

    More links here

  • Music

    Bandcamp music page

    What's on my Bandcamp music page

    Soundcloud playlist (music sampler)

    "As Pluto Descends" trilogy

    10 greatest albums of the 'album era'
  • Associated sites

    Terrestri(e)alism

    EcoCultureLab: Enter the Feverish World

    EcoCultureLab blog

    Media+Environment journal

    M+E+ blog

    UKR-TAZ: A Ukrainian Temporary Autonomous Zone

  • This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States license.
  • wordpress visitors

Get a free blog at WordPress.com

Theme: Mistylook by Sadish.


Skip to toolbar
  • UVM Blogs
    • WordPress
      • About WordPress
      • Get Involved
      • WordPress.org
      • Documentation
      • Learn WordPress
      • Support
      • Feedback
    • UVM Blogs Home
    • Site Directory
  • Sign In