Ishchenko: For nuance

15 04 2014

In “Maidan or anti-Maidan? The Ukraine situation requires more nuance,” sociologist Volodymyr Ishchenko attempts to carve out a progressive socialist position on the Ukraine conflict, one that would “support progressive wings of both Maidan and anti-Maidan, and try to unite them against the Ukrainian ruling class and against all nationalisms and imperialisms on shared demands for social justice.”

A few quotes:

“The anti-Maidans in the east are no more irrational than Maidan protestors who were hoping for the European dream but gained (quite expectedly) a neoliberal government, IMF-required austerity measures and increasing prices. In the eastern Ukrainian protests, “Russia” – with its higher wages and pensions – plays the same role of utopian aspiration as “Europe” played for the Maidan protestors. The economic situation in Ukraine continues to deteriorate and the national currency has lost more than 50% of its value in two months, so the protestors in the Donetsk region are talking more about the socio-economic problems the Ukrainian state was not able to solve for 23 years: collapsed enterprises, unemployment and low wages. They demand nationalisation and decent rewards for their labour.

“It will sound paradoxical for those who celebrated grassroots self-organisation in the Maidan, but the anti-Maidan protests in eastern Ukraine are even more grassroots, decentralised, network-type and leaderless at the moment. Neither the Party of Regions nor the Communist Party of Ukraine play the same role of political representation for anti-Maidan as the three former opposition parties did for Maidan. The so called “representative of south-eastern Ukraine”, the former Kharkiv region governor Mykhailo Dobkin, whom Russia was going to invite to the negotiations with the EU and US on an equal basis with the Kiev government, was violently booed by protestors in Lugansk. Equally, they do not trust the oligarchic elite of eastern Ukrainian origin; or the wealthiest person in Ukraine, Rinat Akhmetov, who has taken on a peacemaker role; or the new Donetsk governor Serhiy Taruta. And they do not want the discredited and corrupt Yanukovych back.

“The social base of the protest seems to be more plebeian, poorer and less educated than on Maidan; we see more workers and pensioners and not so many intellectuals and higher-educated professionals who would help to formulate clear demands and defend them in the media.

“This is precisely why these protests can be so easily influenced from the outside. It is not difficult to intervene, provoke and manipulate a decentralised revolt of scared people to serve Russian interests.”

Political scientist Andreas Umland‘s response to the piece is also worth sharing:

“Interesting position from Volodymyr Ishchenko. Though, I think, it compares apples with oranges. The practical political weight, social implications and policy impact of Russian imperial nationalism and Ukrainian ethnic nationalism are of different orders. Also, as far as I understood Marxism, bourgeois modernity is clearly preferable to pre-modern autocracy. Equidistance would thus mean imbalance. Individual emancipation can come only come after national emancipation. Civil and political rights precede social rights. A neo-liberal Ukraine, as a candidate for, and later member of, the EU, may not be ideal, but is still preferable to the other viable alternatives. Following an utopian ideal should not lead one to normative relativism. It is not all black and white. But it is also not all grey.”



16 responses

16 07 2014
il resto del carlino

Complimenti per l’articolo, davvero interessante, spero tu possa pubblicare altre informazioni così interessanti in futuro, tornerò presto a leggerti. Buona giornata

25 01 2018
Showbox For Pc

ShowBox for PC. We don’t officially have a PC/Windows version of ShowBox, however we can still run it. Follow the steps below -.
Download BlueStacks [Comfortable with Windows XP/Vista/7/8/10]; Install the emulator and run it. Download ShowBox APK file via emulator. Install it

14 02 2018
agario unblocked

h I actually do not really understand about this concept but it seems this concept was created to build so

16 02 2018
io games unblocked

io games unblocked a99 io

27 02 2018
agario private server

vate Server: It is agario server that everyone can play.
Click on the link to play Agario Private Server free of charge.
Playing Agario Pvp Server is easy and convenient.
To play Agario click on the link above the comment.
Playing Agario is now easy Site:
We have just opened agarprivateseor

22 03 2018
Kerala Lottery Result Today

This is such a great information ever

22 03 2018
agario games

Handheld LCD games were uploaded to the Internet Archive (a website where volunteers build a digital library of Internet sites and other cultural artifacts) earlier this week, and are now playable through a web browser via MAME emulation.

5 04 2018
earth day history

Wonderfull keep sharing Awesome post

3 08 2018

nYeiYEtd8Q Ishchenko: For nuance nx597j root

9 08 2018

28wmQ3gT5Y Ishchenko: For nuance evercoss m50 star frp

20 09 2018

wRMK37M0l6 Ishchenko: For nuance download firmware for printer

20 09 2018

hNTXZdNsU1 Ishchenko: For nuance how to root zte zmax pro with or without pc step by

13 10 2018

jika aku kembali, ku mohon kamu jangan pernah menangis, karena air matamu mengingatkan ku akan rasa sakit yang pernah kau berikan !
cara mengobati wajah lumpuh sebelah karena bell’s palsy,

6 11 2018

bisakah aku menggapai mu di kemudian Waktu ??

19 12 2018

nice from information, sogood is verry goodlah diantos indoirmasi nu sanesna
Cara Mengatasi Pandangan Mata Kabur Dan Buram Tanpa Kacamata

21 12 2018
Sesak Nafas

ohmasa so go on this like lah pokonamah kana artikel na

Leave a Reply

Skip to toolbar