Right vs. left: Starodubtsev & international solidarity with Ukraine

24 10 2026

Please note that a few corrections were made to this post, mainly clarifying the Bolbochan discussion, at 12:45 PST on 18 October.

On Sunday October 18 in Lviv, Ukraine, a group of some fifteen mostly masked men attacked Vladyslav Starodubtsev — a veteran of the Russo-Ukrainian war, historian of the socialist and labour movements in Ukraine, and curator of the Veterans’ Programme at Lviv’s Institute for Documentation and Exchange (INDEX). The attack was intended to disrupt Vladyslav’s lecture, “Left-wing Lviv: A Brief History of a Long-standing Tradition.” 

The irony in the attack is multi-fold. Starodubtsev joined the Armed Forces of Ukraine at age 22, leaving the service a year later in April 2026. Following that he joined INDEX, where he coordinates the Veterans’ Programme and the Fellowship Programme for Active Servicemembers of the Ukrainian Defence Forces. These programmes are designed to preserve the testimonies of Ukraine’s defenders and support their documentary projects in the fields of culture and the humanities. To say that he is doing more for his country than far rightists stalking Ukraine’s streets (instead of, say, fighting on the frontlines) is not too difficult. But Starodubtsev is best known in the West as one of the more prominent left-wing voices in Ukraine’s defense against Russia; he’s been featured on Jacobin Radio, Veterans for Peace, International Viewpoint, Against the Current, and several other venues.

What’s more emblematic of this attack, however, is that it comes in the midst of what can reasonably be called a coordinated assault on Ukraine by the global far right, with Russia’s neo-imperialist war effectively supported now by Donald Trump’s MAGA machine and all the other putinophilic parties across Europe and the world — France’s Le Penists, the UK’s Faragists, Germany’s AfD, and Brazil’s Bolsonaristas who are favored to win back power this weekend, among others.

That this assault now includes Trump’s and Elon Musk’s mutual desire to withdraw support from Ukraine — in Musk’s case this includes not just the dampening of capacity of the Starlink and Starshield networks on which Ukraine has become dependent for its survival, but also an evident alignment with Russian efforts to prop up Republican candidates in the upcoming U.S. elections (see Joohn Choe’s excellent analysis of one instance of this in the Texas senatorial race) — makes this far-right alignment all the more global.

It is in this context that Ukraine’s own beleaguered, and perhaps bewildered, far right seems to be seeking opponents from among leftist academics on its own streets. This suggests either that they are taking cues directly from Moscow, in support of the latter’s claims that Ukraine is run by “neo-nazis,” or, in a more generous interpretation, that they are simply ignorant both of global politics and of their own history, a history in which left-wing thinkers advocating for Ukraine’s self-determination long predated the WW2-era Right that they now glorify (Dmytro Dontsov, Stepan Bandera, and others). That that left-wing history includes canonically Ukrainian author-activists like Ivan Franko and Lesia Ukraïnka, not to mention the many other social democrats and socialist revolutionaries from Mykola Kostomarov and Mykhailo Drahomanov to Mykola Khvylovy and the writers and artists of the ultimately “executed renaissance” of the 1920s and 1930s — but that it is also a history in which the paradigmatically “nationalist” city of Lviv figures as central — is part of what the far right abjures.

In the aftermath of the attack, some on the far right seized upon Starodubtsev’s critique of a particular historical figure, Ukrainian People’s Army colonel Petro Bolbochan. Starodubtsev had written an analysis in which Bolbochan’s reputation appears rather ambiguous, with criticism of him coming during his lifetime not only from leftist Ukrainian People’s Republic leaders like Symon Petliura, but also fellow nationalists like military commander Yevhen Konovalets. Needless to say, this kind of analysis is what historians do. Starodubtsev has responded, since the attack, on his critics’ defamatory misrepresentations of his writing on Bolbochan here.

I launched a Change.org petition urging Lviv authorities to condemn the assault on Starodubtsev on Monday, and it has since garnered over 350 signatures. The petition has been picked up by the independent socialist forum New Politics, whose history of support for Ukraine’s anti-imperialist struggle against Russia is longstanding. The attack has also been condemned by PEN Ukraine and by international solidarity organizations including the Ukraine Solidarity Network. I would also direct attention to INDEX’s official Statement on the Attack on Vladyslav Starodubtsev.

It’s crucial that Lviv city authorities be pressured to investigate the attack thoroughly and penalize the attackers. (They have initiated an investigation, but to date no conclusions have been reported.) This is all the more important since the attackers included a former city councilor, Ihor Sholtys (from the ostensibly liberal and pro-European party Holos, which raises questions about that party as well).

Ukraine’s efforts to defend itself from Russian aggression depend on its abilities to retain the democratic values of an open society. Wartime may make that more challenging, but it doesn’t take away the imperative to remind ourselves why and from what Ukraine needs defending. It is not only from Russia, whose imperialism is authoritarian and, at the very least, fascist-leaning. It is also from the fascist-leaning authoritarianism that takes home-grown forms wherever it is seeded, and whose global forms are actively working against Ukraine today.

Added later: On October 25, the RUTA Association for Central, South-Eastern, Eastern European, Baltic, Caucasus, Central and Northern Asia Studies in Global Conversation published its own “Statement of Solidarity with Vladyslav Starodubtsev,” which you can find here.


Actions

Information

Leave a Reply




Skip to toolbar