Presentation: SHAFR 2015

For the 2015 Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations (SHAFR) conference, I organized a panel on “Patterns and Problems: The US Consular Service in the Nineteenth Century.” Joining me in presenting papers were Prof. Lawrence Peskin of the Morgan State University, who spoke about his research on the Montgomery family, a trading family who provided the US consul in Alicante, Spain from 1793 to 1823; and Prof. Mattew Raffety of the University of Redlands, who spoke about Nicholas Trist’s time as a – very loquacious – US consul in Havana between 1831 and 1845. Our chair was Prof. Nancy Shoemaker of the University of Connecticut, and our commentator was Prof. Kristin Hoganson of the University of Illinois.

Here’s my paper on “Charting the US Consular Service in the Long Nineteenth Century”:

Phelps – SHAFR 2015 Presentation

Welcome to this work in progress!

I am in the midst of a large research project on the US Consular Service, which was part of the US Department of State from 1789 until 1924, when it was combined with the diplomatic corps to create the US Foreign Service. The research project will definitely consist of a data set and book; I’m also considering various opportunities for a digital humanities project element. I won’t be done for quite a while, but I’m finding all sorts of interesting things, and people keep asking me questions about the service and its records, so I thought I would start this blog as a way of sharing things as I go along.

Unless otherwise noted, everything here is a work in progress. You’re welcome to cite information presented here, but please be aware that I may change my mind about its accuracy as I learn more.

Questions and friendly suggestions are welcome; feel free to email me at nphelps@uvm.edu.

Thanks for visiting!

Prof. Nicole M. Phelps, PhD

Associate Professor of History

University of Vermont

The US Consular Service: A Brief Introduction

The US Consular Service (USCS) was one of three major divisions within the Department of State. The central office staff, including the secretary of state, worked from Washington, collecting information from the field and attempting to garner domestic support for presidential foreign policy. The diplomatic corps dealt with the “high politics” of negotiation and representation; its members were posted to capital cities. Consular officials facilitated trade and protected the lives and property of US citizens abroad; their tasks were myriad, and they carried them out wherever there was need, often in port cities. When the USCS was at its peak size in 1895, there were approximately 90 people working at the State Department in Washington, including messengers and custodial staff; there were just over 40 diplomatic posts, and just under 800 consular posts. In 1924, the diplomatic corps and consular service were combined into the US Foreign Service (USFS), and various consular duties were distributed across various career tracks within the USFS. The US government began closing consular posts and offering those services out of their growing number of embassies abroad. Today, there are approximately 310 Foreign Service posts.

Consuls did all sorts of things. Not only did they facilitate trade, but they negotiated for improved trade agreements, answered a wide variety of queries about the host country for people back in the United States and vice versa, represented the US government at various social and ceremonial functions, aided destitute, ill, and orphaned Americans abroad, handled a variety of estate and inheritance issues, interrogated witnesses for American courts, searched for fugitives from the law, helped smooth over disputes between American tourists and local businessmen, evacuated US citizens and other neutrals during crises, protected naturalized US citizens from compulsory military service in their country of birth, represented US citizens’ legal interests in host-country court proceedings, worked to reunite deserted women and children with husbands and fathers who had begun new lives and families in the United States, and helped to screen potential immigrants. US consuls all over the world engaged in similar activities, and at some posts did even more. In China, consuls operated the extraterritorial legal system, and in imperial settings, they were often deeply involved in politics, especially in times of crisis and revolution. There could only be one legation or embassy per country—indeed, per empire—but there were rarely limits on the number of consular posts in a given country, and so consuls were the ones on the ground in the colonies. They could be directly involved in local politics and served as the channel of communication between officials in Washington and insurrectionists, as they did in the Haitian and Cuban revolutions, for example; arguably, they had much greater influence and importance than their colleagues in the diplomatic corps, who were limited to a removed presence in Paris and Madrid. All consular activities required significant diplomatic skill, and in many cases they also required the consul to determine whether an individual was really a citizen and therefore entitled to consular protection, since passports were rarely required for foreign travel. The stakes in these cases were often very high—if not for the United States as a whole, then for the individuals involved in any given situation.